Is Stealing Wrong? Not on the Left

Dennis Prager

Dennis Prager | Posted: Nov 02, 2021 12:01 AM – for

To most readers of this column, the question is absurd. The reason is not because the question is, in fact, absurd; it is because most readers of this column are conservative, and many are religious.

Am I implying that most leftists do not believe stealing is wrong?

Yes, I am.

As incredible as this assertion is to just about all religious people and virtually all conservatives, most leftists do not believe stealing is wrong. Since I always draw a distinction between those on the Left and liberals, let me add that I suspect most liberals think stealing is wrong. But it almost doesn’t matter because they vote for people who do not think it is.

One proof is the passage of Proposition 47, a California ballot initiative passed in 2014, under which theft of less than $950 in goods is treated as a nonviolent misdemeanor and rarely prosecuted. As a result, in Democrat-run California cities such as San Francisco and Los Angeles, retail theft has soared.

Walgreens stores in San Francisco are racking up four times the average amount of theft in Walgreens stores across the country; spending on security guards in San Francisco is 35 times more than the chain’s average in other cities. Walgreens has been forced to close 22 stores in the city since 2016.

As reported in the San Francisco Chronicle: “The Safeway located in San Francisco’s Castro neighborhood … was a longstanding, 24-hour fixture in San Francisco’s Castro neighborhood. But as of last week, the store’s hours have been cut back to 6 a.m. to 9 p.m … A Safeway spokesperson (said) that the cutbacks are ‘due to an increasing amount of theft at the store.'”

Further proof that the Left doesn’t consider theft wrong — at least when committed by a person of color — was an interview broadcast on NPR last year with the author of a book titled “In Defense of Looting.” The NPR interviewer threw only softball questions to the author.

In the last election, Los Angeles voters elected San Francisco’s previous district attorney, George Gascon, as Los Angeles’s district attorney. It was Los Angeles’s way of declaring that stealing is not wrong. And it is worth noting that it is not only racial minorities and the poor who make these elections possible; it is also prosperous whites. The Los Angeles DA is a wealthy white, and he was supported by a white billionaire, George Soros.

It is hard to believe that millions of Americans do not deem stealing from stores morally wrong, so let’s try to explain how this has come about.

Reason No. 1 is moral relativism. For as long as there has been a Left, it has rejected moral absolutes. As the great British historian, Paul Johnson, pointed out a half-century ago in his magnum opus, “Modern Times,” the secular world applied the relativism of the natural sciences to morality.

My cmnt: This was a show of ignorance and/or deceit by “the secular world” and displays a gross misunderstanding of both Einstein’s theories of Relativity and Heisenberg’s uncertainty principle in quantum theory. Einstein never stated nor believed the dictum “everything’s relative”. He objected to the term relativity and preferred to call his insight into the constancy of the speed of light and all physical laws the theory of invariance. **

My cmnt: Nor does quantum theory overthrow any of this. Heisenberg basically stated the law of indeterminacy or ignorance. The fact that quantum entities behave as both particles and waves and that we cannot know both the location and velocity at the same time does not mean the quantum world is either random or lawless. To the contrary we precisely manipulate the quantum world all of the time with completely predictable results. ***

Reason No. 2 is the reason for reason number one: the collapse of the Judeo-Christian value system and the accompanying abandonment of, and often disdain for, biblical ethics. Biblical morality posits moral absolutes — meaning that stealing is wrong for everyone, certainly people of every color. Yes, one can offer a biblical defense of a starving man stealing food for his starving family. But that is hardly what is happening in San Francisco and other American cities.

Reason No. 3 is Marxist morality. From Marx to the present, Marxism has divided the world not between right and wrong, but between economic classes. Therefore, it is morally acceptable for members of the poorer classes to steal from members of the more affluent classes. This notion has made its way into young people’s minds for decades. About 30 years ago, I spoke to students from four Cleveland high schools. I asked them to raise their hand if they would steal something they really wanted from a department store if they were certain they would not get caught. Nearly all the students raised their hands. When I asked some of them to justify their reasoning, they all said the same thing: they wouldn’t steal from a mom-and-pop store, but they would steal from a department store. It is OK to steal from “the rich.”

Reason No. 4 is leftists’ view of nonwhites, especially blacks, a view that conservatives have never shared. Leftists truly believe that blacks are intellectually and morally inferior to whites. The evidence? They do not believe blacks should be held to the same intellectual and moral standards to which leftists hold whites. Leftists do not defend whites who steal, and they hold whites to higher intellectual standards. Leftists do not argue for lowering math standards for whites, only for blacks.

The bottom line is the Left is immoral. That is why it defends stealing.

My cmnt: This is an important column because the Left is immoral. But I would add that they are mostly immoral because they do not practice what they preach. They simultaneously defund police while hiring expensive personal body guards. They rail about global warming and CO2 while they fly around the world in private jets and get shuttled about town in their private limousines. Like all Bolsheviks they like and enjoy the goods and services of capitalism but hate not just capitalists but especially the middle class. They don’t really condone stealing from themselves nor their friends. They squeal when robbed or cheated or mugged or when they pay their taxes (when they actually pay any). What they hate are freedoms for the masses that they believe only the elite should enjoy. They find this personally galling and distasteful in a very visceral way. Therefore they tear down the walls and dig up the foundations of morality as the fastest way to destroy America and any other free country.

Dennis Prager is a nationally syndicated radio talk-show host and columnist. His latest book, published by Regnery in May 2019, is “The Rational Bible,” a commentary on the book of Genesis. His film, “No Safe Spaces,” was released to home entertainment nationwide on September 15, 2020. He is the founder of Prager University and may be contacted at

** In his original 1905 paper about invariance, “On the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies”, Albert Einstein did call his first postulate the Principle of Relativity.  But later he regretted this name – for scientific reasons because the logical foundation of his theory is constancy, and for philosophical reasons because he saw the silly analogies that people drew between his theory about relativity in physics and their ideas about relativity in ideology, to claim support for their non-scientific ideas about relativism and subjectivism.People extended his scientific claims about the relativity of specific things (time, space, and mass) into non-scientific claims about the relativitity of everything (including values and ethical standards) in all areas of life, as if Einstein was saying “everything is relative.”  But he never said this. by Craig Rusbult, Ph.D.

*** The Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that the exact position and momentum of an electron cannot be simultaneously determined.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s